Assessing the Rising Stars of US Soccer

Ryan Tolmich emphasizes the exceptional form of Christian Pulisic, suggesting that this version of him is the best yet. Achieving such performance requires a confluence of factors: optimal fitness levels, a club willing to empower him, and, most crucially, a player brimming with confidence and skill. Currently, Pulisic embodies all these qualities, and as long as that confidence is sustained, he stands poised to be a standout for the US Men’s National Team (USMNT) in the forthcoming World Cup.

Tom Hindle concurs, pointing out that Pulisic’s fitness is key to his success. His time off during the Gold Cup appears to have rejuvenated him, allowing him to contribute effectively to the USMNT.

Tolmich then reflects on the significant return of Antonee Robinson, who has quickly reestablished himself as one of the top talents in the Premier League after overcoming injury challenges. His presence at Fulham is reassuring, and despite the admirable performances of his USMNT substitutes, Robinson’s return is highly anticipated.

Hindle adds that while Max Arfsten is a capable left back, Robinson’s ability to influence the game at both ends distinguishes him as a game changer, enhancing the team’s dynamics.

Shifting focus to Weston McKennie, Tolmich acknowledges that while his current position as a wing-back may not be ideal, it is evident that he remains a pivotal player for Juventus. His consistent impact at a prestigious club highlights his value, and despite positional changes, he continues to prove his worth.

Hindle suggests that McKennie should consider a return to center midfield, arguing that it could optimize his talents.

The discussion turns to Brenden Aaronson, whose development has been noteworthy. Tolmich praises Aaronson for embracing criticism and using it as motivation to enhance his performance in the Premier League, despite lingering doubts about his contributions. Hindle expresses skepticism but acknowledges that Aaronson deserves continued opportunities to prove himself.

Tolmich presents Chris Richards as a strong candidate for Player of the Year, citing his contributions to Crystal Palace’s recent trophies and his solid performance for the USMNT. On the women’s side, he argues for Catarina Macario, who has returned impressively to the field, leading the team in goals and proving her importance.

Hindle asserts that while Pulisic is an obvious choice for the Men’s National Team, the selection for the Women’s National Team is more complicated due to various injuries and team rotations, suggesting Lily Yohannes as a thoughtful choice.

Tolmich notes a noticeable cultural shift within the USMNT under Mauricio Pochettino’s leadership, which has fostered a more engaged and committed team dynamic. This change has led to significant improvements as they prepare for upcoming friendlies against Belgium and Portugal.

Hindle recalls Pulisic’s absence during the Gold Cup and the resulting controversy, which ignited discussions among current players and legends alike. Tolmich agrees that Pulisic’s potential to achieve unprecedented success in Serie A makes him a player to watch closely, suggesting he could also contend for the league’s MVP and even a Scudetto.

Finally, Hindle highlights the promising narrative surrounding Gio Reyna, suggesting that his return to form adds an exciting element to the team’s prospects.