Struggling Premier League Transfers: A Closer Look at Underperforming Players

Tottenham Hotspur has witnessed a gradual decline in its stature as one of the Premier League’s ‘Big Six’ since the departure of Harry Kane to Bayern Munich in 2023. New signings like Richarlison, Dominic Solanke, and Mathys Tel have been unable to effectively replace Kane’s prolific scoring. Hopes were high for Randal Kolo Muani, who joined on loan from Paris Saint-Germain, given his impressive tally of eight goals during his temporary stint at Juventus last season. However, he has yet to find the net in his first 11 Premier League appearances and has struggled to make a meaningful impact, scoring only in a Champions League match against his parent club, PSG. While physically impressive, Kolo Muani has failed to demonstrate the requisite technical skills and killer instinct to revitalize Spurs’ ambitions for European qualification under the pressure of manager Thomas Frank.

Chelsea’s Jamie Gittens made headlines during a standout 2024-25 campaign at Borussia Dortmund, accumulating 17 goal involvements. His unpredictable style and pace attracted Chelsea’s attention, yet he has not managed to replicate that form since his move. Instead, Gittens has played second fiddle to Alejandro Garnacho, struggling to find his place in the team. Weighed down by a £52 million price tag, Gittens has recorded only two assists in 16 league appearances, and his performance in a recent 2-2 draw against Brentford, where he had just 17 touches before being substituted, raises concerns about his future with both club and country.

Everton’s Thierno Barry was brought in as a leading striker following a promising season with Villarreal, where he contributed 15 goals and assists. However, his time at Everton has been marked by a lack of composure and proficiency in front of goal, managing only two goals in 21 games. Despite showing commendable effort, Barry’s performance has contributed to a struggling Everton side, which has netted only 20 goals in the Premier League since his arrival.

Meanwhile, Jadon Sancho’s loan move from Manchester United to Aston Villa has not yielded the desired impact, with the former Dortmund star failing to register a single goal involvement in 15 appearances. His recent performances have been inconsistent, and questions regarding his attitude persist. Sancho faces a critical six months as he aims to rediscover his form before his contract expires.

At Liverpool, new signings have faced scrutiny, particularly Milos Kerkez, who has struggled to adapt since joining from Bournemouth. His performances have drawn criticism, with observers noting his naivety and inability to adjust to the tactical demands of the squad. Viktor Gyokeres was seen as a potential star for Arsenal, coming off a prolific season at Sporting CP. However, he has found the transition to the Premier League challenging, registering only five goals in 17 appearances.

Manchester United’s investment in Benjamin Sesko from RB Leipzig has raised eyebrows due to his unproven track record in the Bundesliga. Although he has shown promise, Sesko has struggled with finishing, scoring just twice in 16 matches. His injuries have hampered his development, raising doubts about whether he can fulfill expectations.

Nottingham Forest’s Anthony Elanga experienced a successful season prior to his transfer to Newcastle but has yet to translate that form into tangible results, remaining goalless in 25 matches. His decision-making has come under scrutiny, and he risks being benched if his performance does not improve.

Arnaud Kalimuendo, formerly of Rennes, has also faced challenges since joining Nottingham Forest, making minimal impact in the Premier League. His lack of playing time and performances have led to speculation regarding his future.

Lastly, Harvey Elliott’s loan at Aston Villa has not turned out as anticipated, with limited opportunities leading to frustration. Despite his potential, Elliott finds himself trapped in a situation that may not allow him to realize his talent until next season.

Alexander Isak’s highly anticipated move to Liverpool has turned sour, with the striker struggling to regain fitness and form after a drawn-out transfer saga. With injuries impacting his season, Isak faces an uphill battle to turn around what has been a disappointing year.