Assessing the Departure of Alonso: A Managerial Perspective

Tom Hindle: Absolutely not. Managers require time to implement their vision, and in the grand scheme of things, Alonso’s results were not particularly poor. Although there were a few draws and a couple of losses, the team is only four points behind in La Liga and remains competitive in the Champions League. Losses in El Clasico undoubtedly sting, but it was not essential for Alonso to leave. However, it’s uncertain whether conditions would have improved under his leadership.

Ryan Tolmich: Given the chaotic atmosphere on Monday, the situation was indeed precarious. Alonso appeared to lack the respect of the team’s elite players, and when that occurs, a coach typically faces dismissal. Yet, it is questionable whether any coach could manage that locker room effectively. Alonso was the scapegoat this time, but many coaches might find themselves in a similar predicament given the authority dynamics among the players.

TH: Coaching a group of players who are resistant to guidance is a daunting task. Real Madrid needs a strategist but also a charismatic figure who can personify Madridismo. While Alonso achieved some success through his analytical approach, he needed to adapt his style to resonate with the unique culture in Madrid.

RT: Accepting such a position is enticing due to the opportunity to work with some of the world’s best talents, but the reality is that the role is nearly impossible even for seasoned veterans. The repeated hiring of Ancelotti and Zidane over nearly a decade underscores the significant respect they command. Many believed Alonso’s storied playing career would afford him similar respect, but that has not been the case.

TH: Let’s be clear: the players were instrumental in Alonso’s dismissal. While he should have adapted his methods, it was ultimately the lack of commitment from stars such as Mbappe and Vinicius that led to his downfall. They needed to demonstrate their dedication to the coach, even in simple matters such as honoring an opponent. If Alonso requested a guard of honor, that expectation should have been met.

RT: The situation can be nuanced. Alonso will likely reflect on certain moments with regret—instances where he may have been too inflexible or, conversely, too lenient. This is typical for a young coach, and he will gain experience from these lessons. The pressing question remains whether the players will learn as well. While it is important for players to have input, the ultimate responsibility lies with the coach. A cohesive leadership structure must be established in order for the team to function effectively.

TH: Financially speaking, it’s unlikely any player will leave. However, for the club’s welfare, a change is necessary. Vinicius may be the most logical candidate to depart, despite his potential to be the next Cristiano Ronaldo. Selling him could yield significant financial returns while allowing him a fresh start. Although he might be a better team player than Mbappe, the latter holds a dominant position at the club, whether that is justified or not.

RT: Is it a necessity? No. Should it happen? Likely, yes. The team is overflowing with attacking talent, and allocating substantial funds to two left wingers seems inefficient. Mbappe possesses the versatility to play centrally, but that is not his optimal role. It would be more strategic to convert one of these players into an elite striker, midfielder, or defender through trades. This is just one of numerous issues the club must tackle in the coming year.

TH: No one seems capable of managing this club effectively, which requires a comprehensive overhaul. Any other organization would recognize this need and act accordingly. Arbeloa, while possessing some advantage from his academy experience, faces an uphill battle. He may be the best candidate from a limited pool of options.

RT: For the time being, yes. He is familiar with the club’s culture, understands its internal politics, and is regarded positively as a young coach. However, his lack of experience remains a significant concern, especially at a club of this caliber. Perhaps he could follow a path similar to Pep Guardiola, who emerged from challenging circumstances at Barcelona, but it is more likely that the club will reevaluate this position shortly.

TH: The options are vast for Xabi. Being one of the top managers in Europe leaves many avenues open. Barcelona and Manchester United can likely be disregarded due to historical rivalries. Manchester City presents a plausible opportunity, particularly if Pep Guardiola departs at the season’s end. Additionally, Arne Slot may now feel increased pressure at Liverpool.

RT: Essentially, he can choose wherever he desires. Many top clubs will express interest, and it’s plausible that Spain may consider him after the upcoming World Cup. His accomplishments in Germany showcase his coaching abilities, yet he still has lessons to learn to reach greatness. Perhaps his experience in Madrid was such a lesson, and many clubs will be eager to see how he has developed.

TH: He indeed made the right decision. Mbappe has aspired to play for Madrid since childhood, and he is entitled to pursue his dreams—especially if a club is willing to disrupt its wage structure and harmony to facilitate his arrival. He had achieved all he could with PSG, who subsequently thrived following his exit. The pressing question remains: what lies ahead? At 27, Mbappe has yet to significantly enhance a team’s performance. Unless he commits to integrating into a system, he risks simply accumulating goals without meaningful impact. There is little reason to empathize with that reality.

RT: The future remains uncertain. Would PSG’s success in the Champions League sting for him? Certainly, but statistically, it is difficult to argue that Mbappe’s move has been anything but beneficial. He has amassed impressive goal totals along with substantial financial gains and global visibility. While there are certainly sporting challenges to navigate, his talent suggests he will find solutions, even if it requires taking a few setbacks to ultimately move forward.