Manchester United’s Coaching Shake-Up: Carrick Takes Charge Amid Controversy

Ruben Amorim was relieved of his duties on January 5, as Manchester United opted for a proactive approach to management changes for the 2026 season. Amorim’s exit resulted from a series of inconsistent performances and a reluctance to modify his tactical strategies.

Darren Fletcher temporarily oversaw a disappointing draw against Burnley and an FA Cup third-round exit to Brighton. The management reins have now been handed over to Michael Carrick for the remainder of the season, after which the club intends to make a permanent appointment.

Carrick, a former United midfielder, has included familiar faces in his coaching staff, notably former teammate Jonny Evans and his assistant from Middlesbrough, Jonathan Woodgate. Additionally, Steve Holland, who has previously worked with the England national team, has joined the team.

Former United captain Roy Keane has expressed skepticism about the new coaching unit. He engaged in a spirited discussion with Gary Neville on the “Stick to Football” podcast regarding the effectiveness of Carrick’s staff.

Neville remarked, “Steve Holland is a serious operator. While I cannot guarantee success, I believe he enhances Carrick’s coaching team.” In response, Keane questioned the qualifications of the other coaches Carrick has appointed, pointing out that Evans recently left a loans manager role just weeks prior to his new position with the first team.

Keane criticized the rapid transition, saying, “Jonny Evans was on vacation just two weeks ago and is now back working with the first team. This is a significant step up.”

Neville attempted to clarify his position, emphasizing the importance of having qualified individuals like Holland among the coaching staff to ensure effective training sessions. He noted that Carrick would face immense pressure and would need to be well-prepared on the training pitch.

Keane countered, questioning the rationale behind bringing in two coaches whose qualifications he dismissed, asserting, “It would be ideal if we could say all three staff members are exceptionally qualified, rather than singling out Holland.”

After Neville reiterated Holland’s extensive experience, Keane referred to previous experienced coaches at United who did not meet expectations, highlighting the issue of relying on past credentials.

As Carrick and his coaching team prepare for their first significant test against Manchester City at Old Trafford, they will follow up with a challenging fixture against Premier League leaders Arsenal. Currently, United sits seventh in the league, three points behind Liverpool and the top four, but only five points ahead of 14th-placed Tottenham.