A Promising Turnaround for Manchester United Under Michael Carrick

It may be premature to declare a “red revival” or to suggest that the difficult times for Manchester United are over, but there is a notable shift occurring under interim coach Michael Carrick. With three victories in as many matches—highlighted by a Manchester Derby win and a thrilling 3-2 match against Arsenal—the atmosphere at Old Trafford, once somber, has brightened significantly. Although the recent win over Fulham was less convincing, it featured a dramatic conclusion reminiscent of the trophy-laden days during Sir Alex Ferguson’s tenure.

Fans of United are beginning to dream again; a victory against Tottenham on Saturday would position them closer to an elusive five-game winning streak. However, it is clear that many supporters remain cautious, hesitant to celebrate too soon. The question looms whether the improved performances are merely the result of a new-manager bounce or the beginning of a more sustainable transformation. One thing is evident: Carrick, aged 44 and known for his elegant midfield passing during his five Premier League title wins under Ferguson, seems to have effectively engaged a squad that often appeared adrift during the Ruben Amorim period.

In stark contrast to Amorim, who adhered rigidly to a 3-4-2-1 formation that often failed to suit the players, Carrick presents a fresh tactical approach. Amorim departed the club with the worst goals-per-game average and the lowest clean-sheet percentage of any manager in United’s Premier League history.

Carrick’s arrival has been positively received by players who respect his legacy as a United player and understand the high expectations associated with the club. Unlike Amorim, who publicly criticized his squad—calling them “possibly the worst team in United’s history”—Carrick exudes a calm demeanor. He maintains a steady expression during matches, often dressed in a smart overcoat, and conducts his press conferences with professionalism, avoiding the sensationalism that characterized his predecessor.

His more composed leadership style has impressed players, who appreciate his humble approach. More importantly, Carrick has implemented crucial tactical changes. He has abandoned Amorim’s ineffective system in favor of a back four, supported by two defensive midfielders and a fluid front four. This adjustment has allowed captain Bruno Fernandes, United’s most influential player, to operate closer to the opposition goal, maximizing his impact—evidenced by his crucial assist in the stoppage-time winner against Fulham.

Similarly, the new setup has benefited Amad Diallo, who was previously burdened with defensive responsibilities. Now, Amad can focus on being an attacking threat, creating challenges for opposing defenses.

Carrick has also reintegrated Kobbie Mainoo into the squad, a player who had been sidelined under Amorim, and who now adds much-needed creativity in midfield. The interim coach has reinstated Harry Maguire to lead the back line and positioned Luke Shaw in his preferred left-back role, bolstered by the return of Lisandro Martínez to form a solid defensive partnership with Maguire.

Bryan Mbeumo, who takes pride in representing United, has adapted well to a dynamic “false No. 9” role in Carrick’s revamped setup, while Matheus Cunha has showcased his potential with two impressive goals.

Under Carrick’s guidance, United has scored eight goals in three matches, placing them among the top of the scoring charts. Essentially, Carrick has simplified the structure, fitting players into their natural roles, which has allowed individual talents to shine.

However, it would be premature to label Manchester United as title contenders or to anticipate a dramatic rise from their current fourth place. This team still faces significant challenges in securing a top-four finish and qualifying for the next UEFA Champions League season, with strong competition from Liverpool, Chelsea, and Aston Villa.

There is a pressing need for United to acquire a defensive midfielder with aggression, stamina, and creative abilities, such as Adam Wharton from Crystal Palace or Nottingham Forest’s Elliot Anderson.

In conclusion, while United and Carrick have yet to prove themselves conclusively, they have laid a foundation for a potential return to the Champions League—a goal that must be prioritized this season. If Carrick successfully navigates this challenge, his case for a permanent managerial position will be compelling. Having served a lengthy apprenticeship and performed well at Middlesbrough, he is no novice. United fans remain hopeful that he can guide their club away from the turmoil of recent seasons, but belief in that potential remains to be seen.