Analyzing the U.S. Soccer Squad: Key Players and Challenges Ahead

Tom Hindle: The current squad is as close to full strength as possible, considering Pochettino’s evaluations and the injury status of several players. While the absence of Pulisic, Adams, Tillman, and Richards is unfortunate, it is essential to field those who are fully fit. The return of Christian Roldán is encouraging, and Ricardo Pepi certainly deserves another opportunity to showcase his potential, whether as a primary striker or a secondary option behind Folarin Balogun. Furthermore, it is great to see Reyna back in the fold.

Ryan Tolmich: Given the circumstances, the squad is acceptable. The team is grappling with injuries, and Pochettino has had to face the reality that this lineup, despite its potential, cannot operate at its highest capability. In this context, it is sensible to assess Reyna and Scally’s development and to evaluate the center-back options in Richards’ absence. Additionally, McKennie’s role should be reconsidered, as he thrives under pressure, similar to his experiences at Juventus. Therefore, the current squad composition is reasonable, even if some decisions might differ from what others would prefer.

TH: Regarding Pepi, with Haji Wright and Balogun established as known quantities, his role remains uncertain. The U.S. will bring three strikers to the World Cup, ensuring Pepi won’t lose his place. However, the question remains: will he be the lead striker or merely a backup? This camp should provide insights into his standing within the squad.

RT: The center-back situation is crucial. With Richards confirmed as one of the three World Cup starters, the other two positions are still up for grabs. Without Richards in camp, the remaining players must compete fiercely for these spots. Will Tim Ream secure one of them? Can Mark McKenzie and Miles Robinson prove their worth? Will Auston Trusty make a significant impression? With most positions filled, the center-back situation remains uncertain, and this camp may shed light on the contenders.

TH: Center backs are critical; any defensive lapses can have significant consequences, not only on match outcomes but also on players’ reputations. Trusty is under considerable scrutiny and must demonstrate his capabilities during this camp to secure a spot.

RT: The spotlight is undoubtedly on the strikers. For the first time since the Copa America, the U.S. has its top three strikers—Balogun, Pepi, and Wright—together in camp. This creates a genuine competition for the starting position, and may the best player prevail!

TH: If Mauricio is willing, it might be time to unleash Gio Reyna’s full potential.

RT: Tanner Tessmann has an opportunity to impress, as the U.S. is still searching for a partner for Adams in midfield. Currently, Tessmann appears to be in the lead. If he performs well, especially without Adams providing support, he may convince Pochettino of his capabilities in the midfield role.

TH: While the Americans have not consistently excelled (with the exception of the Gold Cup), they are currently experimenting with different combinations. These upcoming matches present a challenging environment for such testing. With Pulisic sidelined, the focus has shifted more to performance than results.

RT: Given the current squad, it’s unlikely that most players called up would be starters at the World Cup under ideal circumstances. The absence of several key players—Christian Pulisic, Tim Weah, Malik Tillman, Weston McKennie, Chris Richards, and Antonee Robinson—looms large, particularly when facing strong opponents. A victory would certainly be welcome, but the task becomes considerably more challenging with the current lineup.

TH: McKennie is a focal point; Musah needs to embrace the process. If he can impress the new manager at Atalanta, his chances for inclusion in March will improve. However, Pochettino’s lack of faith in McKennie is concerning, indicating deeper issues than mere club-level adjustments.

RT: Musah’s situation is intriguing; while McKennie will likely find a role—either as a starter or impactful substitute—Musah currently appears marginalized. A significant change is necessary for him to alter his standing, and given his situation at Atalanta, this may prove challenging.

TH: In terms of goalkeeping, Matt Freese has clearly established himself as the primary option. Matt Turner has not participated in consistent top-flight football for nearly two years, despite his recent loan to the New England Revolution. It raises the question: would a rational coach select him? This marks a notable decline for Turner, but it is the right decision.

RT: The indication is that Freese is firmly the number one choice. Despite Turner’s recent playing time, he was excluded from the squad, which suggests he is not currently viewed as a contender for the top position. This comes even after his training stint at Crystal Palace leading up to this camp. It is evident that Turner has significant ground to cover, and time is not on his side.