Concerns and Projections for U.S. Soccer Players Ahead of World Cup

Tom Hindle expresses concern regarding Christian Pulisic, noting that despite his previous successes in American soccer, he is currently facing challenges that have led to a cautious approach from AC Milan manager Max Allegri. Hindle suggests that Pulisic’s career may be characterized by standout moments rather than consistent performances throughout a season.

Ryan Tolmich offers a more optimistic perspective, stating that while Pulisic is grappling with minor injuries, there remains ample time to address these issues before the World Cup. He proposes revisiting Pulisic’s form in April to evaluate if there is cause for greater concern.

Hindle highlights Lautaro Martinez’s exceptional performance, leading with six more goals than any competitor, and commends Weston McKennie for his notable contributions to his team, Inter.

Tolmich acknowledges Martinez’s dominance in the Golden Boot race but argues for McKennie’s integral role in Serie A, emphasizing his value beyond just scoring goals.

Hindle introduces Tanner Tessmann as a key U.S. international who must perform well to secure his World Cup spot, citing his consistent presence in Lyon’s lineup.

Tolmich advocates for Mark McKenzie, who has been pivotal in Toulouse’s strong defensive showing. He suggests that McKenzie is well-positioned for a starting role in the upcoming matches for the USMNT due to his familiarity with a back three formation.

The discussion shifts to Folarin Balogun and Ricardo Pepi, as Hindle notes Balogun’s slight edge despite recent struggles. Tolmich agrees but highlights that Pepi’s performance upon his return from injury could significantly influence the starting position.

Hindle questions the definition of ‘game time’ for younger players, suggesting that while being included in matchday squads is beneficial, actual playing time is crucial for development.

Tolmich supports the notion that if Albert were to debut at a younger age than Pulisic or Gio Reyna, it would be a remarkable achievement. His inclusion in recent matchday rosters indicates that he is nearing readiness for first-team action.

On the topic of Tim Weah, Hindle expresses disappointment over Weah’s loan move to a club currently out of the Champions League, raising concerns about his positional role and future opportunities.

Conversely, Tolmich sees the value in Weah’s regular play for a competitive team, noting that his role allows for greater attacking opportunities compared to his time at Juventus, suggesting that he is in a supportive environment at Marseille.