Joey Barton Convicted: A Call for Accountability in Social Media and Mental Health Awareness

Prosecutors in the case argued that former England international Joey Barton had “crossed the line between free speech and a crime.” The 43-year-old, boasting 2.7 million followers on X, suggested that Eni Aluko was awarded punditry roles merely to “tick boxes” following the events surrounding George Floyd, frequently questioning her presence in men’s football coverage.

Aluko, a former Lioness, expressed her shock at becoming a target for Barton’s remarks, especially since she had previously received encouraging messages from him. She urged online trolls to consider the real-life impact of their words.

“Joey Barton is an intelligent man. I believe he understands the weight of his actions,” Aluko told Sky News. “Four years prior to these distressing posts, he congratulated me on my achievements, including my move to Juventus and my appointment as a sporting director at Aston Villa. His recent actions seem calculated, malicious, and disappointing. I hope he returns to the values of the person who once celebrated my career.”

Aluko emphasized the severe consequences of social media abuse, noting, “We have seen tragic instances where online harassment has led individuals to take their lives or fall into severe depression. It’s not just hurtful words; persistent harassment and inciting violence can have dire repercussions in the UK.”

After Barton’s conviction, Aluko expressed relief at concluding a challenging chapter, stating she felt “ten times lighter.” However, she criticized social media platforms for their inadequate policing mechanisms.

“Companies like X are not listening and fail to protect users on their platforms. They often reward hate speech, leading individuals like Joey Barton to believe that making extreme statements is a viable way to gain attention for their podcasts,” she said. “A potential solution could involve Ofcom imposing fines on these platforms if they continue to allow racism, sexism, and hate speech to proliferate. Greater accountability is essential.”

Reflecting on the emotional toll the ordeal has taken on her and her family, Aluko hopes it will inspire greater mindfulness regarding online behavior and its consequences. “The amplification of voices like Joey Barton’s can lead others to think they can act similarly. I’m grateful there is now a criminal consequence to consider, which should encourage individuals to regulate their own online conduct and avoid crossing the line.”

Aluko also remarked on the significant personal and financial repercussions Barton now faces, questioning how this incident could affect his future in football. “He must now confront the consequences of his actions. I hope this serves as a moment of self-reflection for him. I believe in rehabilitation and the importance of personal growth, which is ultimately up to him.”

Barton, who previously played for clubs including Newcastle and Marseille, has been absent from professional football since his tenure as manager of Bristol Rovers ended in October 2023. He currently hosts a podcast titled ‘Common Sense with Joey Barton.’