Player Ratings Review: A Solid Performance Amidst Challenges

**James Trafford (7/10):**
Trafford capitalized on his second start in four days, exhibiting composure and alertness throughout the match. He executed a remarkable save, tipping Wissa’s looping header onto the crossbar, and effectively maintained his team’s defensive integrity as the visitors pressed for an equalizer.

**Matheus Nunes (5/10):**
Nunes demonstrated tenacity in his efforts to keep Anthony Gordon in check, earning a yellow card for a significant tackle. His aggressive play could have led to a second booking for a foul on Joelinton, prompting Guardiola to substitute him.

**Abdukodir Khusanov (6/10):**
Khusanov effectively thwarted both Wissa and Woltemade, showcasing his defensive skills despite a notable physical mismatch.

**Max Alleyne (7/10):**
Alleyne delivered another impressive performance following his recall from loan at Watford, particularly notable against a more formidable opponent than Exeter.

**Nathan Ake (6/10):**
Ake had a challenging time against Newcastle’s pace, yet his experience ultimately proved beneficial to the team’s performance.

**Bernardo Silva (6/10):**
Silva had a quiet first half, pulling a shot across the box in City’s only opportunity before playing a pivotal role in assisting Semenyo.

**Nico O’Reilly (6/10):**
O’Reilly took on an unfamiliar holding midfield role and adapted reasonably well before being replaced by Rodri.

**Phil Foden (5/10):**
Foden struggled to connect with his teammates, raising questions about his selection for the upcoming Manchester derby, despite his strong historical performance in the fixture.

**Antoine Semenyo (7/10):**
While not his most dynamic display, Semenyo found himself in the right positions twice to score, affirming his strong start at City.

**Erling Haaland (5/10):**
Haaland was largely uninvolved in the play and, although a controversial decision, his actions denied Semenyo a second goal.

**Jeremy Doku (7/10):**
Doku ignited the opening goal with a dazzling display against Harvey Barnes, delivering a threatening cross.

**Rodri (6/10):**
Rodri played a crucial role in regaining control for City, enhancing their fluidity and reducing Newcastle’s dominance.

**Tijjani Reijnders (6/10):**
Reijnders added threat to City’s counterattacks, making notable contributions in offensive transitions.

**Rico Lewis (6/10):**
Lewis helped his side assert control in the second half with his adept passing.

**Rayan Cherki (7/10):**
Cherki initially struggled to find power in a clear chance but redeemed himself with a decisive finish in the closing moments.

**Rayan Ait-Nouri (7/10):**
Brought on in added time, Ait-Nouri seized the opportunity, showcasing exceptional skill to assist in the second goal.

**Pep Guardiola (7/10):**
Guardiola adeptly managed the team’s injury challenges, ingeniously employing O’Reilly in a holding role. Although the match was not aesthetically pleasing, securing a two-goal advantage was precisely what he aimed for.