Transfer Window Review: Key Moves and Their Impacts

**For Rennes:** Another significant triumph for the often-overlooked talent factory at Rennes! Jeremy Jacquet is set to join the esteemed list of academy graduates who have become international stars, alongside Raphinha, Eduardo Camavinga, Ousmane Dembele, Desire Doue, and Jeremy Doku. Premier League giants Chelsea and Manchester United pursued the 20-year-old, but Liverpool has emerged victorious, securing a £60 million agreement for him to join Anfield in the summer. This fee is substantial given Jacquet’s limited top-tier experience, yet Rennes has successfully retained his services until the season’s end as they aim for European qualification. The Frenchman is on the verge of departing as one of the club’s most notable success stories. Grade: A

**For Liverpool:** Arne Slot is keenly seeking reinforcements in central defense, particularly with Ibrahima Konate set to leave as a free agent this summer and 2025 acquisition Giovanni Leoni on a long recovery path from ACL surgery. Strengthening support for Virgil van Dijk and Joe Gomez was essential, and Jacquet is the ideal candidate, despite his youth. The Reds are investing heavily in the France U21 international, who has significant potential to deliver returns quickly and become a long-term asset at Anfield. Jacquet possesses the attributes of a top-class center-back, combining pace and strength to outmatch opponents, as well as a passing range that can enhance Liverpool’s build-up play. Grade: B-

**For Jacquet:** This move represents a dream opportunity for Jacquet, albeit one accompanied by considerable pressure. Given that he has only recently become a regular starter for Rennes, it’s uncertain if he’s ready for such a step-up. One more year in France could have aided his development. However, opportunities to join elite clubs are rare, and he cannot be faulted for taking this chance. Demonstrating maturity, Jacquet chose Liverpool over Chelsea, reportedly due to concerns regarding playing time at Stamford Bridge. Slot is likely to provide the minutes necessary for Jacquet to continue his progression and position himself for a senior France call-up. Grade: B+

**For Wolves:** Exceptional work! Strand Larsen was a revelation for Wolves last season, prompting Newcastle to bid £55 million for the forward during the summer. After losing Matheus Cunha to Manchester United, Molineux’s hierarchy felt they could not afford to let Larsen go, a decision that backfired given his struggles this season (one goal in 19 Premier League appearances). Thus, to secure £48 million for a player whose true value may be half that is impressive. If the funds are reinvested wisely into the squad, Larsen’s departure will not be felt, especially by fans who have grown frustrated with his performances this season. Grade: A-

**For Crystal Palace:** A significant gamble. Palace urgently needed to sign a striker with Jean-Philippe Mateta eager to leave Selhurst Park before the deadline. Strand Larsen has demonstrated his ability to score in the Premier League—at least during the 2024-25 campaign. However, nearly £50 million is an excessive amount for a player who could be a one-season wonder. While Larsen has netted six goals this season, half came against League Two side Shrewsbury Town. At 25, there is potential for improvement, and Oliver Glasner could help him realize his full capabilities, but it’s important to note that the Austrian may not remain beyond the season. Palace is evidently trying to salvage a season that risks spiraling out of control, and Larsen could thrive in a stronger side than Wolves—but they have undoubtedly overpaid. Grade: C

**For Strand Larsen:** A welcome shift. Following a stellar debut season at Wolves, he faced significant criticism during a tumultuous start to the current season. There was a perception that he underperformed after being disappointed by the club’s refusal to facilitate a transfer to Newcastle last summer. While it’s hard to believe he would intentionally lower his performance, his standards may have slipped subconsciously. Regardless, Larsen now has an excellent opportunity to rediscover his scoring touch with a team that generates numerous chances. Though Palace may not match Newcastle’s stature, this move is crucial for his career as he prepares for Norway’s World Cup campaign. Grade: B+

**For Atalanta:** This is not the farewell they envisioned for a player who will be remembered as a modern legend in Bergamo. They should have capitalized on Lookman’s stock when Atletico first expressed interest last summer, as the Nigerian forward had a stellar 20-goal campaign. Instead, they are selling for a modest €35 million, reflecting his considerable drop in output over the past six months. Lookman was pivotal to Atalanta’s Europa League success in 2024 and their third-place finish in Serie A last season, and they owed it to him to facilitate an earlier departure. Their reluctance now appears to have backfired. Grade: D-

**For Atletico:** Diego Simeone has finally secured his target at a bargain price. Lookman can provide Atletico with a fresh dimension in the final third due to his electrifying dribbling and proficient finishing, skills they desperately need after their recent 0-0 draw with Levante. His match-winning capabilities in Europe could be crucial for Simeone’s pursuit of Champions League advancement. Despite concerns over Lookman’s decline this season, his outstanding performances for Nigeria at the Africa Cup of Nations have alleviated those fears, and Simeone will be confident in guiding the 28-year-old back to peak form. Grade: B+

**For Lookman:** Securing a move to a club with realistic ambitions for major trophies after a disappointing start to the season is a fortunate break for him. Departing Atalanta with just two Serie A goals this season, Lookman is relieved Atletico maintained their interest. There are always questions about how a talented attacker will fit into Simeone’s defensive setup, but Lookman has the potential to thrive and prove to be a success, unlike some past players. Having landed in Madrid, he must now demonstrate he belongs at the elite level. Grade: A-

**For Juventus:** A significant relief. Luiz has become one of the worst signings in Juventus history, a waste of funds that contributed to the dismissal of sporting director Cristiano Guintoli last June. The club was eager to offload the midfielder, who failed to register a goal or assist in 27 appearances during the 2024-25 campaign. Ultimately, Nottingham Forest took Luiz on loan last August, with a conditional option to purchase, but his lack of impact raised concerns about having to bring him back. Juventus is now hopeful that Luiz can impress Villa or another club to facilitate a permanent exit this summer. Grade: C

**For Aston Villa:** A clear indication of desperation. Currently third in the Premier League, Villa has a slim chance at their first English championship since 1981 but has recently suffered injuries to key midfielders—Boubacar Kamara, Youri Tielemans, and John McGinn. Their ongoing issues with the Premier League’s Profit & Sustainability Regulations limit spending capacity, leading to the decision to acquire Luiz on loan. Reports suggest the 27-year-old preferred a return to Villa over Chelsea, and there’s a chance he could regain form under Unai Emery. Unfortunately, evidence over the last 18 months suggests returning to Villa might not revive his career. Grade: D+

**For Luiz:** An unexpected but fortunate opportunity. Luiz’s career took a downturn post his departure, hindered by injuries and poor performances at Juventus, which cost him his spot in the Brazil squad. His struggles continued at Forest, making it unlikely he’ll hit the ground running at Villa. That said, Luiz has everything to gain in the upcoming months. This move is critical for his career as the World Cup approaches, and he’ll undoubtedly feel Emery is the best person to help him recover. Grade: A

**For Barcelona:** Infuriating. Fernandez has been with Barca since 2022, and expectations were high for the recently turned 18-year-old. Hansi Flick had high hopes for his development, including him in the senior squad’s pre-season tour and offering him a Liga debut. Consequently, Flick was taken aback when Fernandez expressed a desire to develop with Paris Saint-Germain. Club president Joan Laporta labeled the situation as “unpleasant,” especially since Barca will receive only €8 million for such a promising La Masia graduate. While this is the nature of football, it remains a bitter disappointment. Grade: F

**For PSG:** Another successful acquisition. PSG has developed a reputation for luring high-profile players from Barcelona, and signing Fernandez is reminiscent of their acquisition of 16-year-old Xavi Simons in 2019. Despite Simons not turning into a star at PSG, he generated substantial income through transfers. Fernandez could follow a similar path, especially considering doubts about his playing time in Paris compared to Barcelona. Grade: B+

**For Fernandez:** A bold move. Having made five appearances this season for an exciting team, his choice to leave for PSG has surprised many at Camp Nou. While understandable that breaking into Flick’s lineup could be challenging, PSG has an even younger and potentially more talented squad. PSG’s focus on emerging talents and willingness to give youngsters opportunities does bode well, but concerns remain about his playing time and development. Fernandez possesses considerable faith in his abilities, but this decision may not be the best for his growth. Grade: C-

**For Arsenal:** A wise decision. Mikel Arteta recognizes Nwaneri’s talent, yet with a strong squad, he has little need for the teenager. Loaning Nwaneri for the season is a logical move, allowing him to thrive under Roberto De Zerbi’s guidance. The Gunners could also earn about £3 million if certain appearance targets are met, making this loan beneficial. Grade: B+

**For Marseille:** An intriguing addition to an exciting squad. Despite being third in Ligue 1, Marseille boasts the league’s top scoring record with 41 goals in 18 games, reducing the immediate need for another forward. However, the extraordinary 18-year-old Nwaneri, who netted nine times for Arsenal last season, is seen as a valuable addition to De Zerbi’s attacking options. It’s unfortunate that the loan agreement lacks a purchase option. Grade: B

**For Nwaneri:** A thrilling experience, albeit temporary. Marseille is an enticing city with an exciting team led by De Zerbi, providing Nwaneri with a chance to play alongside talents like Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang. While competition is fierce among gifted attackers, he will likely enjoy more game time than at Arsenal. This bold move at such a young age is commendable and should enhance his chances to become a regular at the Emirates. Grade: A

**For Barcelona:** A critical step towards alleviating Ter Stegen’s wage burden. Given ongoing financial challenges, Barca would have preferred to sell their captain during the winter window to comply with La Liga regulations. Although West Ham’s interest did not materialize, Girona has agreed to cover part of Ter Stegen’s salary, offering a potential permanent move if he performs well. Grade: C-

**For Girona:** An odd timing with recent success. Girona’s three consecutive league victories have helped them rise to 11th place, although they still possess the league’s worst defensive record. Ter Stegen could provide significant assistance if he remains fit, bolstering their goalkeeping options with strong organizational skills. If healthy, he should prove an upgrade over Paulo Gazzaniga. Grade: B

**For Ter Stegen:** A notable decline. Once Barcelona’s captain and first-choice keeper, Ter Stegen has struggled since a severe injury in the 2024-25 season. With the rise of Wojciech Szczesny and the acquisition of Joan Garcia, he has fallen to third choice. To make Germany’s World Cup squad, a move was necessary, making the loan to Girona a sensible choice for a player reluctant to leave Barca. This opportunity allows him to prove his worth once more. Grade: B

**For Crystal Palace:** A disappointing but expected departure. Palace previously allowed Guehi to leave for Liverpool, but manager Glasner blocked the deal due to the lack of a suitable replacement. With Guehi refusing to extend his contract and his value decreasing, the Eagles had no choice but to sell before losing him for nothing at season’s end. This setback significantly impacts Palace’s aspirations for European qualification. Grade: D

**For Manchester City:** A shrewd acquisition! After spending heavily on potential last year without success, City now has brought in proven Premier League talent for under £100 million, and Guehi should provide an immediate impact alongside Antoine Semenyo. Not only is he an excellent defender, but Guehi’s professionalism adds value to the squad. City has already claimed victory in the winter transfer window by outmaneuvering rivals like Liverpool for key targets. Grade: A+

**For Guehi:** A long-awaited elevation. Having risen through Chelsea’s youth ranks without a senior appearance, Guehi’s career took off at Palace, where he captained the club to its first major trophy. His transition to City comes with risks, especially in a World Cup year, but injuries to key defenders offer him an immediate starting opportunity. Under Guardiola’s mentorship, Guehi has the perfect platform to reach his full potential. Grade: A

**For Atletico:** A favorable outcome. Atletico was reluctant to accept Villa’s loan offer for Gallagher, but Tottenham’s €40 million bid was a windfall, allowing for immediate squad reinvestment. Gallagher performed well under Simeone but became a rotational player this season, so recouping the fee paid to Chelsea is sound business. Grade: B

**For Tottenham:** A timely addition. With midfield depth already tested by Rodrigo Bentancur’s injury, Gallagher’s acquisition is crucial for the beleaguered Thomas Frank. His Premier League experience means he can slot directly into the starting lineup. Spurs deserve credit for swiftly finalizing the deal, avoiding the pitfalls of previous seasons. Grade: B

**For Gallagher:** A welcome return to London. Gallagher’s desire to remain at Chelsea was evident, yet he needed regular playing time, which he was not receiving. His move to Tottenham provides that opportunity, and with the World Cup approaching, he’ll be motivated to impress. Despite the toxic atmosphere at Spurs, this transfer enhances his chances of national team selection. Grade: A

**For Al-Hilal:** An unexpected outcome after significant investment in Cancelo. Al-Hilal paid €25 million for the Portugal defender 18 months ago, but his time in Riyadh has been marred by injuries and poor performances, leading to minimal playing time. His anticipated exit during the winter window was inevitable, and while Inzaghi preferred a player swap, Al-Hilal is satisfied with Barca covering part of Cancelo’s salary. Grade: D

**For Barcelona:** A useful temporary solution for their defensive issues. Coach Hansi Flick aimed to recruit a quality center-back, but financial constraints complicated matters. Cancelo’s signing provides necessary cover in defense, allowing Flick flexibility in positioning players. Although concerns about his fitness and positioning persist, he offers valuable depth. Grade: C

**For Cancelo:** A surprising return to a prestigious club. After his disappointing spell in the Middle East, Cancelo had seemingly reached a career low. His prior successful tenure at Barca makes this loan appealing, and he’ll be eager to prove he can regain his elite form. Grade: A

**For Bournemouth:** The end of any slim hopes for European qualification. Bournemouth began the season strongly, largely due to Semenyo’s impressive performances, but an 11-game winless streak has seen them fall down the table. Losing their best player at this crucial time is detrimental, especially with the most viable replacement opting for Crystal Palace. From a financial standpoint, Bournemouth’s profitable business model remains commendable. Grade: B

**For Manchester City:** A satisfying acquisition, especially with interest across the Premier League’s ‘Big Six’. While questions about Semenyo’s fit in Pep Guardiola’s system arise, his unique combination of pace, skill, and physicality make him an excellent addition. His versatility may lead to departures of other players, solidifying his potential value. Grade: A

**For Semenyo:** A well-deserved step up. Following a challenging youth career, Semenyo’s determination and talent have driven him to success. Leaving Bournemouth on good terms reflects his character. He could soon compete for silverware at City, although concerns about the managerial situation and ongoing financial issues linger. Grade: B+

**For Tottenham:** A puzzling sale. Johnson was Tottenham’s top scorer last season and a pivotal player, yet he was let go. With new management assessing his value differently, the sale was necessary. Although the transfer fee is acceptable, Spurs may regret parting with a player who could have contributed significantly. Grade: B-

**For Crystal Palace:** A potentially astute acquisition. Following a strong start to the season, Palace needs depth, and Johnson could provide that, adding a much-needed goal threat. Despite the substantial investment, he has the quality to make an immediate impact. Grade: B+

**For Johnson:** A strategic move in the current context. Although he preferred to stay at Spurs, regular playing time was essential ahead of the World Cup. Palace offers an opportunity to play for an ambitious team, keeping him in London. Johnson is poised to integrate well into his new team and could thrive in this environment. Grade: A

**For West Ham:** The first step towards recouping losses on Fullkrug. Initially seen as a valuable acquisition, his time at West Ham has been marred by injuries and ineffective performances. The hope is for a successful loan in Milan that leads to a permanent transfer this summer. Grade: C

**For Milan:** A perplexing move reflective of their current situation. With financial constraints and a thin attacking roster, Milan’s decision to bring in Fullkrug, despite his injury history, appears risky. However, his physical presence may offer some tactical advantages. Grade: D+

**For Fullkrug:** An unexpected opportunity. Few would have anticipated him landing at Milan while struggling at West Ham. His agent deserves credit for facilitating this chance. Despite uncertainties regarding playing time, this opportunity could reignite his career. At 32, he must capitalize on this unexpected chance. Grade: A

**For Real Madrid:** A tactical decision. Madrid may regret letting Endrick go during a busy season, but sending the frustrated forward out on loan was in the club’s best interest. With Lyon covering the loan fee and half of his wages, this is a no-brainer for Los Blancos as it benefits all parties. Grade: B+

**For Lyon:** A potentially transformative signing. Lyon, sitting fifth in Ligue 1 but with a struggling attack, has secured one of the world’s most talented teenagers. Endrick’s arrival is considered a significant coup, offering fresh hope as they aim for a strong second half of the season. Grade: A

**For Endrick:** A crucial opportunity to revive a stalling career. Under Xabi Alonso, his prospects at Madrid dimmed, but a loan to Lyon could be transformative. Endrick’s talent remains undeniable, and this chance to play regularly could elevate him back into contention for Brazil’s national team. Grade: A.