Zirkzee’s Struggles at United: A Misguided Move or Just Bad Timing?

Joshua Zirkzee’s transfer to Manchester United was anticipated as a pivotal moment for the club, ushering in a new era of attacking creativity. However, it has unfortunately transformed into a cautionary tale. Signed in the summer of 2024 for a fee exceeding £36 million, the Dutch international joined United with a stellar reputation following an impressive spell at Bologna. Under manager Thiago Motta, Zirkzee emerged as a player on the brink of fulfilling his potential, showcasing a blend of physicality and exceptional technical skills that helped Bologna achieve an unexpected qualification for the Champions League.

Nevertheless, Zirkzee’s transition to the Premier League has proven challenging. Since his arrival in Manchester, he has found it difficult to score regularly, often appearing out of sync within United’s tactical framework. Although his link-up play has garnered some praise, his inability to convert chances has earned him considerable criticism from fans at Old Trafford. The pressure has mounted during the first half of the 2025-26 season, with Zirkzee starting only four of his 14 Premier League appearances thus far. In total, he has scored nine goals in 65 matches for the club.

Dutch football legend Ruud Gullit has been candid in his evaluation of Zirkzee’s career decisions. In an interview with Gambling Insider, the former AC Milan star expressed concern that Zirkzee’s growth has been hindered by the negative atmosphere that has engulfed United in recent seasons. Gullit suggested that the forward should have prioritized his development in Italy rather than pursuing the allure of the Premier League.

“Joshua Zirkzee made a mistake moving to Manchester United; he should have stayed in Italy,” Gullit stated. “When he left Bologna, he should have joined Juventus or AC Milan and continued in Serie A. He arrived at United during a turbulent period for the club, which was not the right time for him. There have been rumors about him potentially moving to Roma in the summer. I hope he takes that opportunity or finds another Italian club, as it would be a better fit for him.”

Zirkzee has been at the center of intense speculation, with multiple top Italian clubs reportedly interested in bringing him back to Serie A. Juventus has been linked with a loan deal to bolster their title challenge, while AC Milan remains a long-time admirer of the player. Roma was viewed as a likely destination, particularly before the sacking of Ruben Amorim in January altered United’s plans.

Despite considerable interest and Zirkzee’s evident struggles, a winter transfer did not materialize. United’s management was reportedly reluctant to allow his departure without securing a high-caliber replacement first, especially as the club strives to reclaim a Champions League spot. As a result, Zirkzee remained at United, but the absence of a January exit has only delayed what many perceive to be an impending separation.

As the season nears its conclusion, focus has shifted to a potential summer resolution regarding Zirkzee’s future. Roma is seen as the frontrunner to secure his services, eager to acquire a more dynamic player for their attack. For Zirkzee, a transfer to the Stadio Olimpico would signify a fresh start in a league that values his tactical acumen and playing style.

Gullit’s public endorsement of a move to Roma underscores the belief that Zirkzee requires a change of environment to rediscover his best form. While the Premier League is often regarded as the pinnacle for international stars, Zirkzee’s experience suggests that a stylistic fit can be more crucial than the league’s prestige. If a summer transfer is realized, it would offer Zirkzee the chance to leave behind the negative energy surrounding Old Trafford and prove that his time in Manchester was merely a temporary obstacle in his promising career.